Retired Circuit Judge Tony Johnson Calls for Immediate Action to Restore Accountability in Treasure Island City Government

Treasure Island, FL — December 17, 2024 — In a strongly worded letter addressed to the City Commission of Treasure Island, retired Circuit Judge Tony Johnson alleges significant failures in leadership and accountability within the city’s government in the wake of two devastating hurricanes. Judge Johnson’s letter outlines what he describes as a usurpation of authority by the City Manager, supported by the City Attorney, resulting in severe delays in permitting and the displacement of residents.

Key Allegations from Judge Johnson’s Letter:

The City Manager allegedly exceeded his authority by initiating inspections of every structure in the city without the Commission’s approval, contrary to the City Charter.
Misrepresentations were allegedly made by city staff and the City Manager, claiming FEMA required these inspections, despite FEMA’s guidelines allowing for an alternative permitting process.
The City Commission unanimously chose the traditional permitting process (FEMA Option Two) after hearing public outcry, yet Judge Johnson asserts the City Manager continued with the inspection process (Option One), contrary to the Commission’s decision.
City staff allegedly manipulated substantial damage determinations, leading to delays in permitting and unnecessary hardships for displaced residents.
Judge Johnson criticized the city’s leadership, stating, “You have failed the citizens that elected you.” He called on the Commission to take immediate corrective actions, including firing the City Manager and restoring the decision-making authority of elected officials.

A Call to Action: Judge Johnson emphasized the urgent need for accountability and resolution to ensure displaced residents can return to their homes. “People are on the edge of civil disobedience because you have allowed them to be out of their homes for months. They will repair their homes and move back in, with or without a permit,” he wrote.

Judge Johnson also revealed that he has engaged a law firm to investigate potential legal violations, including Sunshine Law breaches and due process concerns, stemming from the city’s handling of the permitting crisis.