Impact
How restricted funding hinders nonprofits

This series reflects topics of interest of the Catalyst’s Impact Council. Each quarter, our council of local nonprofit thought leaders selects one topic to explore. We post the results of that exploration in pieces like this one.
Part 1 of 2.
They foster civic engagement and leadership, drive economic growth and strengthen the fabric of our communities.
Every person in the United States benefits from the work of nonprofits in one way or another, whether they realize it or not. As America’s governmental and social institutions change, nonprofits are playing a larger role than ever in our daily lives.
“Especially when we include quality of life nonprofits who provide services in the arts, health, personal development – nonprofits represent opportunities as well as needs,” says Marlene Spalten, President and CEO of the Community Foundation Tampa Bay, about the ubiquity of nonprofits.
The Increasing Importance of Nonprofit Aid
In fact, nonprofits have never been a bigger part of the U.S. economy, according to an analysis of the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey.
Over the past 15 years, employment in the nonprofit sector has grown 33%, compared to 9% job growth in the for-profit private sector. Nonprofits have passed local government to become the second-largest source of employment in the country. In Pinellas County, more than 7% of all workers are employed at nonprofits.
Despite this employment growth, local nonprofit leaders say they’re still struggling to keep up with community need. The pandemic exacerbated challenges like hunger and housing shortages, and as governmental programs face funding shortages and budget cuts, nonprofits step in to pick up the slack.
“We have most definitely seen a greater need for community services from local nonprofits since the pandemic began,” says Spalten. “Mental health, environmental resiliency, and education are areas in which there were setbacks during the pandemic from which we need to recover.”
The Impact of Restricted Funding
When donors give to nonprofits but require that their contributions be used only for specific projects, those funds are restricted. While restricted grants serve a purpose by addressing specific needs, they can create challenges when it comes to covering administrative costs. When donors limit their contributions exclusively to program expenses, nonprofits struggle to pay for essential administrative functions.
“Restricted gifts are by nature generous. However, one could say that restriction shows a lack of trust in the organization that it is meant to empower,” says Michelle Curtis, Chief Development Officer and Vice President of Philanthropy at YMCA of Greater St. Petersburg. “We are grateful for every donation, whether it is restricted or unrestricted – however, it is important to remember that while a restricted gift will go towards an intended purpose or specific program, it can also have the unintended consequence of limiting overall impact.”
Program and administrative staff are the backbone of any nonprofit organization. Nonprofits can’t function without leadership and skilled labor in areas like finance, human resources, legal services and marketing. The problem, oftentimes, is finding the funding to pay those people.
Nonprofits also report that with the conditions held by restricted grants, tracking their progress is no easy feat. Fulfilling all of the different reporting requirements can be difficult without adequate staff, and restricted grants often have shorter time frames than general operating funds, meaning there is less time to gather data and prepare reports.
Donor restrictions add complexity to nonprofit financial reports due to the timing of funding, which makes accurate and reliable accounting especially important. The following example from Propel Nonprofits shows an income statement and balance sheet for the fictional nonprofit Family Advocacy Network (FAN), illustrating how these rules work.
In the example, FAN receives a three-year, $60,000 grant to support a new program for the years 2018, 2019 and 2020. The FAN example demonstrates the impact on the income statement of a multi-year grant. Accounting rules require a nonprofit to record all the income of a multi-year grant in the year it is received.
Fictional income statement showing the accounting required to accurately document a donor-restricted grant. Image: propelnonprofits.org
Coming in part 2: Exploring the benefits of unrestricted grants, and the importance of trust-based philanthropy.