Connect with us

Create

Wagon wheels and flowing fiddles: Old Crow’s Ketch Secor

Bill DeYoung

Published

on

Old Crow Medicine Show (with Ketch Secor in striped jacket and bow tie). Photo by Brooke Stevens.

Old Crow Medicine Show co-founder and longtime frontperson Ketch Secor is a true renaissance man – he has one foot, maybe two, in old-timey Appalachian folk and string band music.

That’s how Old Crow began 25 years ago. The music – with Secor on lead vocals, fiddle and a couple other key instruments – has progressed and expanded and crossed the (admittedly thin) borders into country, Americana and even country/rock. They even have a drummer now.

There is, however, no mistaking the fact that the band’s music is primarily acoustic, mostly rural, and therefore snaps nicely into multiple genre scenarios: Old Crow has played the Grand Ole Opry, Madison Square Garden, Stickyz Rock ‘N’ Roll Chicken Shack in Little Rock, England’s Royal Albert Hall and the curb outside a drug store in tiny Boone, North Carolina. That’s where flatpick guitar legend Doc Watson and his daughter “discovered” them in 2000.

The band’s 25th anniversary tour will visit Ruth Eckerd Hall in Clearwater Wednesday, April 9.

Secor and his high school chum Chris “Critter” Fuqua were thick as thieves in 1980s and ‘90s Harrisonburg, Virginia. Fuqua left the band last summer; in a letter to fans on the Old Crow website, Secor poured out his sorrow at losing his longtime partner to substance abuse and mental illness.

In addition to writing songs for Old Crow, Secor has authored a children’s book (Lorraine: The Girl Who Sang the Storm Away) and a musical play (Hootin’ Holler).

He also happens to be the co-author of the biggest barroom singalong since “Rocky Top.” Old Crow’s sole “hit single” is “Wagon Wheel,” which Secor adapted from a scrap of tune Bob Dylan left behind in the 1970s.

We discuss “Wagon Wheel” near the end of this interview.

 

St. Pete Catalyst: Tell me about your stage play, Hootin’ Holler.

Ketch Secor: Well, I grew up watching stage musicals, especially in my youth, and participating in community theater in the various small towns that I lived in. And I always figured I was going to get on the stage, one way or another. But then when I was about 12 or 14, I figured out how to make music – and that became a quicker means to an end than being in plays.

But my love continues for musical theater, and so I just always wanted to throw my hat in the ring, and show folks what I could do when given the task. This show I wrote along with Old Crow co-founder Critter Fuqua, my best buddy, and then a playwright who is an actor on the TV show Nashville, who we met because of the work he does with the theater community in Nashville.

It’s sort of like a futile pursuit. It’s sort of like Sisyphus and the rock when it comes to trying to get your Broadway show going. It takes about 20 years and about $200,000. I haven’t spent that much, or waited that long; it’s been more about 10 years and I haven’t actually sunk any money into it. Maybe that’s why I’ve only gotten as far as regional theater in staged readings, in Virginia.

 

What’s it about?

It’s a country music story about a hero’s journey to a town much like Nashville, and the things that our hero learns along the way. About the traditional arts. Only to find, by the time he gets to Nashville, that’s not what Nashville’s all about any more.

And so he has to adapt to a new style of Nashville, and he’s very good at it but it doesn’t make him feel good on the inside. And that’s a bit of a conundrum for this chap. But he ends up saving the whole kit ‘n kaboodle, and suddenly fiddles flow like wine, once again. Sounds fun, right?

 

It sounds autobiographical. Bringing an old-timey string band to Nashville, 25 years ago, wasn’t that kind of like pushing a stone up a hill for you?

Yeah, very much so. Most of my best work is autobiographical anyway, ‘cause my life in music has been such a riveting tale! And has echoes of other people’s stories, but not so much contemporary ones. I don’t feel as on the same page with a band coming to Nashville right now and what they contend with – and what the trail looks like that they are going to take to the top of the mountain. It’s a different trail and it’s a different mountain.

 

Wasn’t it improbable that Old Crow would find success? Wasn’t it more likely you might make a record, but wind up busking on the streets again?

No, I really thought we’d be big. I thought that little voice, that chip on my shoulder, was a motivator. I couldn’t have thought of higher cotton than the Station Inn, and then the Ryman Auditorium. I think of that wonderful line in “America the Beautiful,” “along the fruited plain.” Our plain was pretty well fruited, if you know what I mean. It seemed like every couple of hairpin turns, there would be a bounty a-waitin’ on us. And we’d get those victor’s spoils. And just enough to fill us up for the next height.

You know, when you start on the curb, it’s all up from there. Every success is existentially better.

 

I think 25 years is a pretty good shelf life for anybody, much less an Appalachian string band.

Part of the challenge has been keeping the lineup, keeping the through line to traditional music, and yet still growing. Which is really a hard task. My baseball metaphors always run out at this point because, y’know, you don’t keep a team together for five years. Three years. You’ve got a new shortstop, you’ve got a new outfielder, you’re bringing up this stable of pitchers. You’re constantly re-tooling it.

But in Old Crow Medicine Show, the lineup shifts were much more dramatic. They took a lot longer to find new stakeholders and yet we’ve managed to keep out here doin’ it, staying on the road. The best part about it is I’m still growing in it. I’m still learning new things. In fact, all the time.

 

Was Critter leaving a terrible loss?

Yeah, it really was, but it was a loss that happened again and again, so we really had to learn how to just deal with it. Because Critter left the band probably six or seven times over the course of 25 years, and most recently, within one year, Critter had a very dramatic departure. He was back in, we got our picture made, spent a bunch of money on a bunch of videos, wrote a bunch of songs …. Oh, you’re leaving? Oh, bye again!

 

I’ve heard different versions of the “Wagon Wheel” story. Can I hear it from you?

I was completely in the study of Bob Dylan from about age 12 to 18, in a really intense way.

“Wagon Wheel” was not the first Bob Dylan song that I attempted to re-write. I’d also re-written “It’s Alright Ma, I’m Only Bleeding,” and I took a quick stab at a Quixotic version of “Tangled Up in Blue,” in which I was the merry prankster. I saw the materials as kinda like the Bible, meant to be dog-eared and flipped through and scribbled in the margins.

That’s when I heard an outtake from Bob’s movie Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid. A film I’d seen three times already. And I just couldn’t get the song out of my head. Then I went home one day, and in about an hour wrote these three verses. F—ked around with the melody a little bit. Then I saw that I was done, and I was like “This is gonna be great!”

 

At some point, of course, you have to credit Dylan. How did that work?

Nothing happens for the longest time. Because I go so deep into playing traditional music that I don’t ever play this song. I start a band, then another band, then Old Crow takes hold, and we start having some early successes. But we never touched that song. We’re only playing the music of the (19)20s and back.

Then we went to Nashville. And suddenly we’re showcasing for all these fancy people in the music business, and they’re all saying “So what have you got that you wrote?”

We said, we don’t really do that. But let’s play you some rockin’ 18th century shit! You’ll love this! And they said that’s cool, but this is a songwriter town. We need songs.

And I’d almost forgotten it … but I said “I got this song.”

And they said “Wow, that’s a good one.”

So we had to get it published. We had a great young, scrappy manager who figured out who to get in touch with. And a guy in Los Angeles just happened to know the right guy, and suddenly it was done: 50/50, Secor/Dylan. It’s like a magic trick.

For tickets to the April 9 performance, click here.

 

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Avatar

    Sarah Moylan

    April 2, 2025at8:45 am

    Fans should also check out Mason Via, formerly of Old Crow Medicine Show. He recently played at Seven C Music in St Petersburg and is the Pre-party band for Billy Strings this Friday in St Augustine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We appreciate your taking the time to share your perspective. Note: Catalyst and Cityverse are non-anonymous platforms. Please include your full first and full last name, as well as your email when commenting (your email address will not be published). Comments without these elements will not be published. Comments are held for moderation per our posting guidelines - please read them.

By posting a comment, I have read, understand and agree to the Posting Guidelines.

The St. Pete Catalyst

The Catalyst honors its name by aggregating & curating the sparks that propel the St Pete engine.  It is a modern news platform, powered by community sourced content and augmented with directed coverage.  Bring your news, your perspective and your spark to the St Pete Catalyst and take your seat at the table.

Email us: spa**@************st.com

Subscribe for Free

Subscription Form

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2026 St Pete Catalyst

Share with friend

Enter the details of the person you want to share this article with.